TDF's most overrated player!

[sennafan24]

List the 5 darts players you believe to be the most overrated. Closing date is 7pm on Friday evening.

The 5 players with the most mentions will be entered into a poll to decide the overall winner.

[sennafan24]

Adams.
RVB.
Duzza.
MVG.
Part.

[Safc]

DVDB
Humphries
Aspinall
Fatpot
Dobey (like him but is massively overrated)

[Tommo]

Adams
Hankey
Durrant
RvB
Hopp

[sennafan24]

Adams
Hankey
Durrant
RvB
Hopp

I forgot about Hopp. Good pick.

[Greipel]

Sherrock
Jim Williams
De Zwaan
Kyle Anderson
Part

[The Gronk]

Adams
Smith
White
Van Barneveld
Chisnall

[Randall]

Adams
Durrant
Hankey
Barney
Waites

[Jimmi]

Hopp
Chizzy (sad face)
Ian Shite
John Henderson (Sorry Randall)
Michael Smith

[Randall]

Hopp
Chizzy (sad face)
Ian Shite
John Henderson (Sorry Randall)
Michael Smith

[Jimmi]

Hopp
Chizzy (sad face)
Ian Shite
John Henderson (Sorry Randall)
Michael Smith

I like Hendo but he hasn't won a single thing in the PDC.
Maybe a pie eating contest against Adrian Lewis but that would be it.

[Mabbsy]

Keegan Brown
Kevin Painter
Max Hopp
Benito van de Pas
Darren Webster

[sennafan24]

Does anyone actually rate Benito and Ian White in the first place?

[Rogg]

Does anyone actually rate Benito and Ian White in the first place?

Everyone is rated highly by somebody, and as rubbish by somebody else. The word means practically nothing to me as there's such wild variation.

Whose 'rating/s' have been people contesting with their selections so far?

[sennafan24]

Everyone is rated highly by somebody, and as rubbish by somebody else. The word means practically nothing to me as there's such wild variation.

Whose 'rating/s' have been people contesting with their selections so far?

To explain one of my picks.

MVG: Rated by many fans and pundits as the 2nd best player of all-time and by some as the very best. For me, he isn't close to Taylor and isn't better than Bristow.

[Randall]

Does anyone actually rate Benito and Ian White in the first place?

Everyone is rated highly by somebody, and as rubbish by somebody else. The word means practically nothing to me as there's such wild variation.

Whose 'rating/s' have been people contesting with their selections so far?

I looked at the current polls on here and of course my own bias.

[Emulsfier]

Michael Shit
Fluke Humphries
Max Flopp
Postbox
Adams

[Rogg]

Everyone is rated highly by somebody, and as rubbish by somebody else. The word means practically nothing to me as there's such wild variation.

Whose 'rating/s' have been people contesting with their selections so far?

To explain one of my picks.

MVG: Rated by many fans and pundits as the 2nd best player of all-time and by some as the very best. For me, he isn't close to Taylor and isn't better than Bristow.

Vastly more fans and pundits rate him accurately than overrate him, though? There are collections of idiots standing behind every opinion imaginable.

So it would be interesting if people explained whose rating they're using in each case. I'd like to know. I will try to name names for mine. Probably Oche.

[sennafan24]

Vastly more fans and pundits rate him accurately than overrate him, though? There are collections of idiots standing behind every opinion imaginable.

Hmmmm, I think most would rank him higher than Bristow, which I disagree with.

[Rogg]

I expect this is probably easier if you watch Sky without using the mute button half the time lol.


Raymond van Barneveld (Sky assorted, for years)
Glen Durrant (Mardle)
Mikuru Suzuki (Nicho)
Ian White (Dan Dawson)
Scott Mitchell (himself, and Mardle)


(...and some memorable vintage ones which deserve a mention for having been so brilliantly strange:)

Niels de Ruiter (Tony Green)
Chris Mason (Sid Waddell)