The darts forum definitive all time top 20 -4th place poll

[Randall]

Its clear who the top 3 are so we move onto 4th place.
Again I will list who I believe to be the obvious choices but if your vote is for someone else say so in the comments

[Randall]

This will surely be a waltz to the finishing line for johnny boy

[SuperSwede]

I voted Gary Anderson who I believe should actually be 3rd with Bristow 4th.

[Ross, Bob]

I voted Gary Anderson who I believe should actually be 3rd with Bristow 4th.

Nice.

[Wolflanternbumbag]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

[Randall]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

Gando cant cope with price
Imagine how much worse it would be with eric

[Wolflanternbumbag]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

Gando cant cope with price
Imagine how much worse it would be with eric

Would see a hideous amount of doubles missed from Ando.

[Randall]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

Gando cant cope with price
Imagine how much worse it would be with eric

Would see a hideous amount of doubles missed from Ando.

Folly to think gando beats eric.

[tungsten tossers]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

Gando cant cope with price
Imagine how much worse it would be with eric

Eric would have made mincemeat out of today's snowflakes..
I can just imagine Eric reacting to a roar from lice

[Randall]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

Gando cant cope with price
Imagine how much worse it would be with eric

Eric would have made mincemeat out of today's snowflakes..
I can just imagine Eric reacting to a roar from lice

He absolutely would have
I don't think the young folk today appreciate quite what eric was.

[Wolflanternbumbag]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

Gando cant cope with price
Imagine how much worse it would be with eric

Eric would have made mincemeat out of today's snowflakes..
I can just imagine Eric reacting to a roar from lice

He absolutely would have
I don't think the young folk today appreciate quite what eric was.

I don’t think Price would be intimidated by him though, would like the challenge

[Randall]

Gary Anderson has more talent than Bristow, but Bristow was a better competitor, more bottle etc.

Gando cant cope with price
Imagine how much worse it would be with eric

Eric would have made mincemeat out of today's snowflakes..
I can just imagine Eric reacting to a roar from lice

He absolutely would have
I don't think the young folk today appreciate quite what eric was.

I don’t think Price would be intimidated by him though, would like the challenge

I like price but he doesn't like it up him
Eric would have rammed it right up him.

[sennafan24]

Bristow would easily get in the head of Gando and Headshaker.

Bristow was a better player than both as well.

[Emulsfier]

Bristow would easily get in the head of Gando and Headshaker.

Bristow was a better player than both as well.

Makes me wonder how bad Fatpot would have had to have been scraped off the wall had his incident been with Bristow rather than Manley.

[SuperSwede]

I love Bristow but I think there is a lot of assumption that his career would have maintained the same trajectory it was on if it weren't for the dartitis but that's an unknown and he used to say himself his competition wasn't up to much.

Gary Anderson has won what he has won in the crossover of periods of dominance of both Taylor and MVG who I say are the two best of all-time.

(plus he has a winning record against Price despite having been in basically semi-retirement mode or injured for the last two years)

[sennafan24]

I love Bristow but I think there is a lot of assumption that his career would have maintained the same trajectory it was on if it weren't for the dartitis but that's an unknown and he used to say himself his competition wasn't up to much.

Yeah, Lowe, Wilson, and Bob Anderson were shit. The averages he posted on those boards in the mid-1980s are just as impressive as the best averages we see today.

[Captain Hobo]

I love Bristow but I think there is a lot of assumption that his career would have maintained the same trajectory it was on if it weren't for the dartitis but that's an unknown and he used to say himself his competition wasn't up to much.

Gary Anderson has won what he has won in the crossover of periods of dominance of both Taylor and MVG who I say are the two best of all-time.

(plus he has a winning record against Price despite having been in basically semi-retirement mode or injured for the last two years)

That is completely pointless. Until the last 2 years Price was a pretty average player.

It's 4-2 to Price in the last 2 years, but that is also too small a sample size to attach much meaning.

[SuperSwede]

I love Bristow but I think there is a lot of assumption that his career would have maintained the same trajectory it was on if it weren't for the dartitis but that's an unknown and he used to say himself his competition wasn't up to much.

Yeah, Lowe, Wilson, and Bob Anderson were shit. The averages he posted on those boards in the mid-1980s are just as impressive as the best averages we see today.

There was little to no depth in terms of troubling the best 5 or 6 players, tournaments basically started at the quarter finals stage mostly.

[SuperSwede]

I love Bristow but I think there is a lot of assumption that his career would have maintained the same trajectory it was on if it weren't for the dartitis but that's an unknown and he used to say himself his competition wasn't up to much.

Gary Anderson has won what he has won in the crossover of periods of dominance of both Taylor and MVG who I say are the two best of all-time.

(plus he has a winning record against Price despite having been in basically semi-retirement mode or injured for the last two years)

That is completely pointless. Until the last 2 years Price was a pretty average player.

It's 4-2 to Price in the last 2 years, but that is also too small a sample size to attach much meaning.

I agree it's pointless, why I put it as an aside in brackets only as someone mentioned that Gary couldn't handle him. As Price has improved Gary has gotten old, injured and semi-retired. Prime Gary would more than handle any of Price's antics because he'd just smash him off the board.

Taylor pretty much had a 50-50 record against Wright in his last two years and slightly the worse of it against MVG, you wouldn't and couldn't use that as the basis for saying he couldn't handle them.

[Captain Hobo]

I love Bristow but I think there is a lot of assumption that his career would have maintained the same trajectory it was on if it weren't for the dartitis but that's an unknown and he used to say himself his competition wasn't up to much.

Gary Anderson has won what he has won in the crossover of periods of dominance of both Taylor and MVG who I say are the two best of all-time.

(plus he has a winning record against Price despite having been in basically semi-retirement mode or injured for the last two years)

That is completely pointless. Until the last 2 years Price was a pretty average player.

It's 4-2 to Price in the last 2 years, but that is also too small a sample size to attach much meaning.

I agree it's pointless, why I put it as an aside in brackets only as someone mentioned that Gary couldn't handle him. As Price has improved Gary has gotten old, injured and semi-retired. Prime Gary would more than handle any of Price's antics because he'd just smash him off the board.

Taylor pretty much had a 50-50 record against Wright in his last two years and slightly the worse of it against MVG, you wouldn't and couldn't use that as the basis for saying he couldn't handle them.

What is Prime Gary though? 2015-2018? And only 2 World Titles in that time.

Bristow was at the very top for a lot longer than that and won 5 World Titles, even before getting Dartitis.