jrwfsl147 wrote:Never claimed they were.
You've piqued my interest so here is a list of number of games at both World Championships where both players had a 90 plus average.
Starting from the start. For ease of following the WDC will be referred to as the PDC.
Using darts database for the stats.
1994
PDC: 4 (Priestley/Wilson, Taylor/Anderson, Taylor/Brown, Taylor/Priestley)
BDO: 0
1995
PDC: 1 (Taylor/Lowe)
BDO: 7 (Barney/Wallace, Monk/Thynne, Barney/Monk, Barney/Adams, Barney/Burnett, Fordham/Williams, Adams/Gregory)
1996
PDC: 2 (Priestly/Warriner, Taylor/Priestley)
BDO: 5 (Beaton/Stompe, Clark/Barney, Beaton/Adams, Burnett/Baxter, Fordham/Beaton)
1997
PDC: 3 (Priestley/Harrington, Priestley/Evison, Taylor/Priestley)
BDO: 8 (Carter/Adams, Wallace/Taylor, Barney/Wallace, King/Baxter, King/Scholten, Wallace/Williams, Wallace/King, Wallace/James)
1998
PDC: 2 (Taylor/Harrington, Taylor/Priestley)
BDO: 10 (King/Clark, Widdows/Adams, Burnett/Painter, Monk/Widdows, Hankey/King, Fordham/Barney, Barney/Beaton, Hankey/Monk, Barney/Monk, Barney/Burnett)
1999
PDC: 6 (Burgess/Harrington, Taylor/Lowe, Manley/Smith, Manley/Burgess, Taylor/Warriner, Taylor/Manley)
BDO: 11 (Wallace/Cunningham, Barney/Paffrey, Hankey/Carter, Mason/Davies, Adams/Gregory, Painter/Widdows, Baxter/Burnett, Fordham/King, Mason/Adams, Barney/Mason, Barney/Baxter)
2000:
PDC: 5 (Lowe/Harrington, Smith/Part, Taylor/Warriner, Priestley/Manley, Taylor/Priestley)
BDO: 11 (Barney/Mason, Beaton/Hunt, Coote/Adams, King/Fitton, Fordham/Beaton, Painter/Widdows, Monk/Davies, Mason/Fordham, Baxter/Monk, Hankey/Mason, Baxter/Stompe)
2001
PDC: 6 (Scholten/Burgess, Harrington/Anderson, Deller/Burnett, Taylor/Fitton, Part/Harrington, Taylor/Part)
BDO: 16 (Walton/Davies, King/Mason, Baxter/Crooks, Fordham/David, Walton/King, Pusa/Porter, Baxter/Adams, Barney/Beaton, Hankey/Hinkley, Painter/Clark, Mardle/Baxter, Hankey/Barney, Fordham/Painter, Walton/Mardle, Hankey/Fordham, Walton/Hankey)
2002
PDC: 8 (Lloyd/Roy, Baxter/Smith, Part/Beaton, Taylor/Burgess, Lloyd/Burnett. Manley/Baxter, Taylor/Part, Taylor/Manley)
BDO: 10 (Barney/George, Monk/Walton, Clarys/Barney, Adams/Coote, Taylor/Stompe, Monk/Mardle, Barney/King, Adams/Jones, David/Taylor, David/Adams)
From 2003 on the PDC had more matches than the BDO. Until that point at every world champs both organisations had 31 games.
The BDO won the average-ometer 8 years on the spin.
In that time both players averaged over 90 78 times.
Conversely in the PDC both players averaged over 90 only 37 times.
As such for the decade following the split I can say without a shadow of doubt that the BDO had the stronger standard.
For purposes of completeness I'll keep going until the PDC wins. I'll only count from the last 32 on in the PDC for fairness.
2003
PDC: 7 (Mardle/Evison, Taylor/Mardle, Smith/Ovens, Mason/Lloyd, Part/Harvey, Taylor/Smith, Part/Taylor)
BDO: 8 (Adams/Stompe, Anderson/Fordham, Monk/O'Shea, Davies/David, Barney/Clarys, King/Barney, Davies/Anderson, Barney/Davies)
2004
PDC: 7 (Warriner/Lowe, Dudbridge/Part, Manley/Deller, Painter/Baxter, Taylor/Warriner, Taylor/Mardle, Taylor/Painter)
BDO: 10 (Davies/Adams, O'Shea/Robson, Davies/Duke, Barney/Walton, Fordham/Fitton, O'Shea/Hankey, King/Davies, Fordham/Barney, King/O'Shea, Fordham/King)
2005
PDC: 9 (Baxter/Jenkins, Lloyd/Mason, Dudbridge/Part, Taylor/Priestley, Anderson/Hamilton, Taylor/Painter, Dudbridge/Mardle, Taylor/Anderson, Taylor/Dudbridge)
BDO: 7 (Adams/Richardson, Barney/Veitch, Van der Voort/Eccles, Hankey/Wagner, Adams/Hankey, Barney/Fitton, Barney/Adams)
So after 10 straight defeats the PDC finally pick up a win.
The purpose of this exercise was to prove that the BDO was the stronger organisation following the split. Aside from the awkward first year this has been proven definitively.
I didn't expect it to be quite so dominant but you can't argue with 78-37.