The darts forum definitive all time top 32

[HalloweenJack]

The top 2 are correct and it’s right that ‘Wadey’ is in the top 10 Bristow should be 3rd for me. I’m surprised Alan Warrriner-Little is in the top 10 tbh.

Did you notice that the criteria is based on peak form rather than overall career?

Yes and i stand by my original comment.

Post your top 10 based on peak form alone

I’ve said my top 3 and I would probably have Gary Anderson above Wright I can’t be arsed to do the rest.

[Randall]

Purely on peak gando has to be top 5

[sennafan24]

The top 2 are correct and it’s right that ‘Wadey’ is in the top 10 Bristow should be 3rd for me. I’m surprised Alan Warrriner-Little is in the top 10 tbh.

Did you notice that the criteria is based on peak form rather than overall career?

Yes and i stand by my original comment.

Post your top 10 based on peak form alone

I’ve said my top 3 and I would probably have Gary Anderson above Wright I can’t be arsed to do the rest.

I was actually interested to see where you would place Wade in your top 10 and your justification for doing so.

As someone who considers some of those who peaked in the PDC on SD boards in the late 2000s and early 2010s [Wade, Lewis, Shitlock] to be underrated relative to some of those who peaked later in the PDC on HD boards [Smith, Bunting, etc], I probably would have been inclined to agree with some of your arguments.

But if you were just gimmick posting, then hey go nuts fatty.

[HalloweenJack]

Did you notice that the criteria is based on peak form rather than overall career?

Yes and i stand by my original comment.

Post your top 10 based on peak form alone

I’ve said my top 3 and I would probably have Gary Anderson above Wright I can’t be arsed to do the rest.

I was actually interested to see where you would place Wade in your top 10 and your justification for doing so.

As someone who considers some of those who peaked in the PDC on SD boards in the late 2000s and early 2010s [Wade, Lewis, Shitlock] to be underrated relative to some of those who peaked later in the PDC on HD boards [Smith, Bunting, etc], I probably would have been inclined to agree with some of your arguments.

But if you were just gimmick posting, then hey go nuts fatty.

WTF

[Randall]

I cant see wade getting into a peak top 10

[sennafan24]

WTF

Still time for you to tell us why you have Wade in your top 10.

[sennafan24]

I cant see wade getting into a peak top 10

I thought this at first. He is probably more of a player renowned for his longevity than peak.

But I suspect his peak in the late 2000s and early 2010s is better than given credit for. When I looked back at a few events from that period last year I was surprised at how well the likes of Wade, Whitlock and Waites played at times.

Wade probably also suffers from peak crossing over with arguably Taylor's best period.

[HalloweenJack]

WTF

Still time for you to tell us why you have Wade in your top 10.

I didn’t realise there was a time limit. Is this a new authoritarian rule for TDF?

[sennafan24]

WTF

Still time for you to tell us why you have Wade in your top 10.

I didn’t realise there was a time limit. Is this a new authoritarian rule for TDF?

No.

In your own time.

[The Thorn]

Did you notice that the criteria is based on peak form rather than overall career?

Yes and i stand by my original comment.

Post your top 10 based on peak form alone

I’ve said my top 3 and I would probably have Gary Anderson above Wright I can’t be arsed to do the rest.

I was actually interested to see where you would place Wade in your top 10 and your justification for doing so.

As someone who considers some of those who peaked in the PDC on SD boards in the late 2000s and early 2010s [Wade, Lewis, Shitlock] to be underrated relative to some of those who peaked later in the PDC on HD boards [Smith, Bunting, etc], I probably would have been inclined to agree with some of your arguments.

But if you were just gimmick posting, then hey go nuts fatty.

Drunk post? Are you going to get the calipers out?

[sennafan24]

Drunk post? Are you going to get the calipers out?

No and no.

[The Thorn]

Drunk post? Are you going to get the calipers out?

No and no.

Fair play for thinking of a way to bring your dislike of Bunting and Bully Smith into a totally unrelated conversation

[sennafan24]

Drunk post? Are you going to get the calipers out?

No and no.

Fair play for thinking of a way to bring your dislike of Bunting and Bully Smith into a totally unrelated conversation

I have made the same argument about BDO Champs from the early 2000s as compared to BDO Champs in the 2010s.

I guess that means I adore Fordham and dislike Waites.

[sennafan24]

Drunk post? Are you going to get the calipers out?

No and no.

Fair play for thinking of a way to bring your dislike of Bunting and Bully Smith into a totally unrelated conversation

Or perhaps I was finding a way to post about my renowned love for Whitlock

[HalloweenJack]

Drunk post? Are you going to get the calipers out?

No and no.

Fair play for thinking of a way to bring your dislike of Bunting and Bully Smith into a totally unrelated conversation

Have a +1

[HalloweenJack]

WTF

Still time for you to tell us why you have Wade in your top 10.

I didn’t realise there was a time limit. Is this a new authoritarian rule for TDF?

No.

In your own time.

My original post was genuine but just for you.

1) Taylor
2) MVG
3) Bristow
4) Wadey
5) Hankey
6) Duzza
7) Stefan Lord
8) Parletti
9) Duff
10) Gary Anderson

[sennafan24]

My original post was genuine but just for you.

1) Taylor
2) MVG
3) Bristow
4) Wadey
5) Hankey
6) Duzza
7) Stefan Lord
8) Parletti
9) Duff
10) Gary Anderson

You really are Thorn's father.

[The Thorn]

1. Taylor
2. MVG
3. Bristow
4. G.Anderson
5. Wright
6. J.Wilson
7. Lewis
8. Barney
9. B.Anderson
10. Lowe

[sennafan24]

Purely on peak gando has to be top 5

I think he is a genuine candidate for top 5, but not a lock.

[sennafan24]

1. Taylor
2. MVG
3. Bristow
4. G.Anderson
5. Wright
6. J.Wilson
7. Lewis
8. Barney
9. B.Anderson
10. Lowe

I'm interested as to why you have Jocky that high.