GSoD: Historical PDC-BDO Head-to-Head

[Randall]

At 6-5 in the Taylor v Adam's semi final, with Adam's on 176, needing 50 with 3 in his hand Taylor went for bull.
Adam's was not amused.

Adam's was trying to get his attention
Taylor just ignored him

[Rogg]

At 6-5 in the Taylor v Adam's semi final, with Adam's on 176, needing 50 with 3 in his hand Taylor went for bull.
Adam's was not amused.

Odd as I remember spineless fairly recently in a BDO game throwing for the bull first dart on 50 with the opponent a mile back. I think it was piss palace. Asked about it later, he said eueghghqg if I've got a dart in me hand for the leg then I'll go for it hackhackaahahahaaha.

Clearly he's changed his mind since he... matured.

[Randall]

At 6-5 in the Taylor v Adam's semi final, with Adam's on 176, needing 50 with 3 in his hand Taylor went for bull.
Adam's was not amused.

Odd as I remember spineless fairly recently in a BDO game throwing for the bull first dart on 50 with the opponent a mile back. I think it was piss palace. Asked about it later, he said eueghghqg if I've got a dart in me hand for the leg then I'll go for it hackhackaahahahaaha.

Clearly he's changed his mind since he... matured.

Doesn't like it up him

[Ross, Bob]

At 6-5 in the Taylor v Adam's semi final, with Adam's on 176, needing 50 with 3 in his hand Taylor went for bull.
Adam's was not amused.

Odd as I remember spineless fairly recently in a BDO game throwing for the bull first dart on 50 with the opponent a mile back. I think it was piss palace. Asked about it later, he said eueghghqg if I've got a dart in me hand for the leg then I'll go for it hackhackaahahahaaha.

Clearly he's changed his mind since he... matured.

In his defence, his mind was riddled with cancer.

[Rogg]

At 6-5 in the Taylor v Adam's semi final, with Adam's on 176, needing 50 with 3 in his hand Taylor went for bull.
Adam's was not amused.

Odd as I remember spineless fairly recently in a BDO game throwing for the bull first dart on 50 with the opponent a mile back. I think it was piss palace. Asked about it later, he said eueghghqg if I've got a dart in me hand for the leg then I'll go for it hackhackaahahahaaha.

Clearly he's changed his mind since he... matured.

Doesn't like it up him

A hairy marshmallow hiding down Olly's blouse. Absolute nightmares.

[Rogg]

2009

BDO Representatives

Mark Webster (playing PDC)
Simon Whitlock (playing PDC)
Anastasia Dobromyslova (playing PDC)
Brian Woods
Ted Hankey
Tony O'Shea
Darryl Fitton
Francis Hoenselaar
Scott Waites

I never counted it like that.

Webster, Whitlock, etc may have qualified as BDO players, but they entered the tournament as PDC players.

Fine. I put the brackets there for that reason. It's easy to scrub their wins if you want.

You've got to have a system when counting as the history of this event is one hell of a maze. If Duzza were representing the BDO last year (and everyone seemed to agree that he was), then all previous players who qualified as BDO players were too.

[Rogg]

2011

BDO Representatives

Dave Chisnall (playing PDC)
Scott Waites
Ted Hankey
Tony O'Shea
Martin Phillips
Dean Winstanley
Jan Dekker


Michael van Gerwen 5-3 Scott Waites
Mark Walsh 5-2 Tony O'Shea
Scott Waites 5-2 Mark Walsh
Michael van Gerwen 5-2 Tony O'Shea
Dean Winstanley 5-4 Ian White
Ted Hankey 5-2 Raymond van Barneveld
Dean Winstanley 5-2 Raymond van Barneveld
Ted Hankey 5-2 Ian White
James Wade 5-4 Dave Chisnall
Terry Jenkins 5-3 Dave Chisnall
Dave Chisnall 5-4 Justin Pipe
John Part 5-2 Jan Dekker
Jan Dekker 5-1 Arron Monk
Mark Webster 5-3 Jan Dekker
Adrian Lewis 5-4 Martin Phillips
Martin Phillips 5-2 Vincent van der Voort
Martin Phillips 5-2 Co Stompe

Ted Hankey 10-9 Michael van Gerwen
Mark Walsh 10-9 Dean Winstanley
Mark Webster 10-8 Martin Phillips

Mark Walsh 16-14 Ted Hankey


Group Stage: PDC 8-9 BDO
Last 16: PDC 2-1 BDO
QF: PDC 1-0 BDO

Total: PDC 11-10 BDO

[Ross, Bob]

2011

BDO Representatives

Dave Chisnall (playing PDC)
Scott Waites
Ted Hankey
Tony O'Shea
Martin Phillips
Dean Winstanley
Jan Dekker


Michael van Gerwen 5-3 Scott Waites
Mark Walsh 5-2 Tony O'Shea
Scott Waites 5-2 Mark Walsh
Michael van Gerwen 5-2 Tony O'Shea
Dean Winstanley 5-4 Ian White
Ted Hankey 5-2 Raymond van Barneveld
Dean Winstanley 5-2 Raymond van Barneveld
Ted Hankey 5-2 Ian White
James Wade 5-4 Dave Chisnall
Terry Jenkins 5-3 Dave Chisnall
Dave Chisnall 5-4 Justin Shite
John Part 5-2 Jan Dekker
Jan Dekker 5-1 Arron Monk
Mark Webster 5-3 Jan Dekker
Adrian Lewis 5-4 Martin Phillips
Martin Phillips 5-2 Vincent van der Voort
Martin Phillips 5-2 Co Stompe

Ted Hankey 10-9 Michael van Gerwen
Mark Walsh 10-9 Dean Winstanley
Mark Webster 10-8 Martin Phillips

Mark Walsh 16-14 Ted Hankey


Group Stage: PDC 8-9 BDO
Last 16: PDC 2-1 BDO
QF: PDC 1-0 BDO

Total: PDC 11-10 BDO

"Ted Hankey is the GOAT."

[Randall]

2011

BDO Representatives

Dave Chisnall (playing PDC)
Scott Waites
Ted Hankey
Tony O'Shea
Martin Phillips
Dean Winstanley
Jan Dekker


Michael van Gerwen 5-3 Scott Waites
Mark Walsh 5-2 Tony O'Shea
Scott Waites 5-2 Mark Walsh
Michael van Gerwen 5-2 Tony O'Shea
Dean Winstanley 5-4 Ian White
Ted Hankey 5-2 Raymond van Barneveld
Dean Winstanley 5-2 Raymond van Barneveld
Ted Hankey 5-2 Ian White
James Wade 5-4 Dave Chisnall
Terry Jenkins 5-3 Dave Chisnall
Dave Chisnall 5-4 Justin Shite
John Part 5-2 Jan Dekker
Jan Dekker 5-1 Arron Monk
Mark Webster 5-3 Jan Dekker
Adrian Lewis 5-4 Martin Phillips
Martin Phillips 5-2 Vincent van der Voort
Martin Phillips 5-2 Co Stompe

Ted Hankey 10-9 Michael van Gerwen
Mark Walsh 10-9 Dean Winstanley
Mark Webster 10-8 Martin Phillips

Mark Walsh 16-14 Ted Hankey


Group Stage: PDC 8-9 BDO
Last 16: PDC 2-1 BDO
QF: PDC 1-0 BDO

Total: PDC 11-10 BDO

"Ted Hankey is the GOAT."

Losing to mark walsh?
On tv?

[Rogg]

Losing to mark walsh?
On tv?

O'Sheep, Winston and Mankey were all sorted out by him.

Good old Walshy proper scrubbing the mushrooms.

[Randall]

Losing to mark walsh?
On tv?

O'Sheep, Winston and Mankey were all sorted out by him.

Good old Walshy proper scrubbing the mushrooms.

A blessed draw

[Rogg]

So far.


2007: PDC 15-8 BDO ----- [2 of these BDO wins by then-active PDC players]
2008: PDC 18-14 BDO ----- [5 of these BDO wins by then-active PDC players]
2009: PDC 10-12 BDO ----- [4 of these BDO wins by then-active PDC players]
2010: PDC 9-16 BDO
2011: PDC 11-10 BDO ---- [1 of these BDO wins by a then-active PDC player]
---
2015: PDC 18-7 BDO
2016 PDC 18-11 BDO
2017 PDC 17-9 BDO
2018: PDC 17-10 BDO
2019: PDC 21-6 BDO ----- [4 of these BDO wins by a then-active PDC player]


Total: PDC 154-103 BDO

[Rogg]

The first five years: PDC 63-60 BDO

The last five years: PDC 91-43 BDO

[Rogg]

You may have fairly vivid memories of the 2012 edition. Let's see.

[Rogg]

2012

BDO Representatives

Ted Hankey (playing PDC)
Dean Winstanley (playing PDC)
Christian Kist
Tony O'Shea
Wesley Harms
Martin Phillips
Jan Dekker
Scott Waites


Mark Webster 5-3 Scott Waites
Scott Waites 5-1 Co Stompe
Scott Waites 5-2 Phil Taylor
Robert Thornton 5-0 Ted Hankey
Ted Hankey 5-3 Steve Beaton
Michael van Gerwen 5-0 Ted Hankey ----------
Kevin Painter 5-4 Dean Winstanley
Dean Winstanley 5-2 James Hubbard
Dean Winstanley 5-1 Simon Whitlock
Mervyn King 5-1 Jan Dekker
James Wade 5-1 Jan Dekker
Arron Monk 5-1 Jan Dekker
Tony O'Shea 5-4 Adrian Lewis
Gary Anderson 5-4 Tony O'Shea
John Part 5-4 Tony O'Shea
Wesley Harms 5-2 Terry Jenkins
Wes Newton 5-2 Martin Phillips
Terry Jenkins 5-2 Martin Phillips
Wes Newton 5-2 Wesley Harms
Christian Kist 5-1 Wayne Jones
Christian Kist 5-4 Raymond van Barneveld
Mark Walsh 5-4 Christian Kist

Scott Waites 10-8 Robert Thornton
Dean Winstanley 10-5 Arron Monk
Christian Kist 10-9 Wes Newton
Raymond van Barneveld 10-4 Wesley Harms

Michael van Gerwen 16-12 Scott Waites
Dean Winstanley 16-12 Kevin Painter
Raymond van Barneveld 16-10 Christian Kist

Michael van Gerwen 16-8 Dean Winstanley


Group stage: PDC 13-9 BDO
Last 16: PDC 1-3 BDO
QF: PDC 2-1 BDO
SF: PDC 1-0 BDO

Total: PDC 17-13 BDO

[Rogg]

...5 of the 13 'BDO' wins above were by Winstanley and Hankey who both had a tour card at the time. That's a very high percentage.

I'll do a separate calculation at the very end to address that. The mushrooms won't like it but nobody cares.

[Ross, Bob]

...5 of the 13 'BDO' wins above were by Winstanley and Hankey who both had a tour card at the time. That's a very high percentage.

I'll do a separate calculation at the very end to address that. The mushrooms won't like it but nobody cares.

Are there any mushrooms left here, besides the forum mascot Oche?

[Randall]

Mvg 5-0 hankey remains my favourite moment in darts history

[Rogg]

...5 of the 13 'BDO' wins above were by Winstanley and Hankey who both had a tour card at the time. That's a very high percentage.

I'll do a separate calculation at the very end to address that. The mushrooms won't like it but nobody cares.

Are there any mushrooms left here, besides the forum mascot Oche?

I hope not but we can never be too careful.

[Randall]

Rentokill came in 2016